Not sure how I feel about all of this. Seems the host of PBS’s “The Good Night Show” on the affiliate “Sprout” was fired for making a fake public service announcement (PSA) before ever joining PBS. Seven years before joining PBS. The PSA’s are rather racy, but nothing you wouldn’t find on Comedy Network or SNL. The liberal part of me is screaming, “Stupid PBS!!!” The conservative parent side of me is saying, “Bad choices have bad consequences.” And so again I’m stuck with the dilemma of humor vs. good parenting.
In my opinion, I think this jerks kids around. They grow used to these characters on TV and almost become attached to them. Heck, I cried when Friends went off the air and was mouthing with Ross, “Did she get off the plane?” at the end of the series. Or take into account Steve leaving Blues Clues to go to college and letting his cousin Joe take care of Blue. Kids old enough can become attached to these characters and can suffer minor anxiety over the departure.
It also reminds me of Pee Wee’s playhouse, when Paul Ruebens got caught, mmmm, finding some “self-pleasure” in a “movie theater”. Of course his Playhouse had long since been cancelled, but kids had no clue Pee Wee was, well, choking little “pee wee” in public. We chuckled as adults and went on and enjoyed him in “Mystery Men” with Ben Stiller.
I’m having trouble seeing how this is wrong. We have no problem letting stars appear on Sesame Street that have seedy pasts. Judging from the press releases and captions, Ms. Martinez alerted her superiors to the short films. Under the “whistle-blower” law doesn’t she have the right to keep her job?
When I sniff around this a little more I wonder if there is, in some way, a double standard. If Ms. Martine had been “Mr. Martinez” would we have had the same reaction?
I think what would have been more appropriate would have been for Ms. Martinez to issue a public statement ( apology or otherwise to parents on the Sprout site ), receive a fine from PBS and then do 5 PSA’s for PBS on STD’s or teen pregnancy.
If you’re interested now in the videos I’ve posted them below as well as PBS’s public statement on their Sprout site. I posted the text in case the link changes. They are rather funny, especially the first one! But let me know your opinion.
And PBS’s Sprout Response
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A Notice To Parents Regarding
The Good Night Show
Late last week, Melanie Martinez, host of The Good Night Show, alerted us to the internet posting of an independent short film that she appeared in seven years ago. PBS KIDS Sprout has determined that the dialogue in this video is inappropriate for her role as a preschool program host and may undermine her character’s credibility with our audience. As a result, PBS KIDS Sprout has decided that she will no longer appear as host of The Good Night Show. Melanie has been an important part of our network and we are disappointed that we had to make this difficult decision.
PBS KIDS Sprout’s foremost priority is to do what is best for our young viewers and their families. We remain committed to The Good Night Show, which debuted last year, as a valuable tool for parents to help children wind down after a busy day. Regularly scheduled programs within The Good Night Show (e.g. Dragon Tales™, Bob The Builder™, Thomas & Friends™) will continue to air in their designated time slots with new short-form content replacing Melanie’s segments. We are developing plans to launch a new season of The Good Night Show with a new host in late 2006.
Posted Thursday, July 20, 2006 at 6:02 p.m. ET
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
And here are the videos in question. ( YouTube has already pulled them.)